Match Guarantee

Matchmaking Decisions · 7 min read

VIDA Select vs Three Day Rule

Two U.S. matchmaking services compared on what each one publishes about itself: price, contract, sourcing, how you see a match, screening and guarantees, with the questions to ask both.

Joe Rickards smiling outdoors

Joe Rickards

Founder and International Matchmaking Educator ·

Editorial image of a client comparing options with a matchmaking advisor
On this page

Disclosure and quick answer

Match Guarantee wrote this comparison and runs a competing matchmaking service. Everything below about VIDA Select and Three Day Rule comes from each company’s own public pages, checked on November 17, 2026. We have not used either service as a client, and this is not a ranking.

The short version:

  • VIDA Select publishes its prices, month-to-month from $1,695 and results-guaranteed programs from $6,000. It searches its own database, dating platforms and a network of fellow matchmakers, and clients approve each match from a full profile with photos before any date.
  • Three Day Rule does not publish package prices on the pages checked. It operates in 15 named U.S. cities plus nationwide, describes a team of recruiters and a free candidate network, and sells a 12-month Million Dollar Matchmaking membership limited to three clients.

Neither guarantees a lasting relationship. The better fit depends on whether you value published pricing and approving matches from photos, or a recruiting-led search in a city where the company has a team.

Side by side

What you are comparingVIDA SelectThree Day Rule
Who it says it serves”Accomplished professionals”Singles in its cities and nationwide, with a separate LGBTQ+ program
Published price$1,695 per month for monthly memberships; $6,000 or more for results-guaranteed programsNot published on the pages checked; “introductory packages to VIP Memberships”
Top tierResults-guaranteed programsMillion Dollar Matchmaking: 12-month membership, unlimited matches, “Only 3 Memberships available”
Where candidates come fromInternal database, dating platforms and a nationwide network of fellow matchmakers; six channels in total”Our team of recruiters search the country”, plus a free network candidates can join
What you see before a dateA full profile with photos; you approve or decline each matchNot described on the pages checked
CoverageSays it finds matches “wherever they are”15 named cities, from Austin to Washington DC, plus a nationwide option
ScreeningClients authorize a public-records background check at onboardingTerms of use say it does not, as a practice, conduct background checks; the Million Dollar tier lists background and social checks
Contract termsMonthly plans may auto-renew; the Premium Guarantee package is non-cancellable once signedPackage terms not published on the pages checked
GuaranteeGuaranteed packages let you decline up to 2 of 3 matches; terms set in a separate agreementTerms of use make no guarantee of matches or lasting compatibility

Sources: VIDA Select FAQ, VIDA terms, Three Day Rule, What We Offer, Nationwide, Million Dollar Matchmaking, Three Day Rule terms.

Pricing and contracts

VIDA Select is one of the few matchmakers that publishes a number. Its FAQ says packages range from $1,695 per month for flexible monthly memberships up to $6,000 or more for results-guaranteed programs, with the right package depending on location, goals and search depth. Its terms add two details worth reading before you sign: monthly subscription packages may include auto-renewal, and the Premium Guarantee package is “non-cancellable once signed”, with its guarantee and refund provisions set out in a separate service agreement.

Three Day Rule does not list prices on the pages checked. Its homepage describes memberships “from introductory packages to VIP Memberships”, and its What We Offer page notes that “services vary based on package”. Its top published tier, Million Dollar Matchmaking, is a 12-month membership with unlimited matches, coaching and date preparation, concierge date planning, 12 months of relationship coaching and, among other extras, a three-carat diamond engagement ring, with “Only 3 Memberships available”.

A month-to-month price is easier to compare, but it can cost more over a long search. The matchmaker cost guide shows how to compare the total commitment of a monthly plan and a fixed package, and the how long does matchmaking take guide explains why the term matters.

How each finds and presents matches

The two companies describe their search differently.

VIDA Select says your matchmaker draws on its internal database, dating platforms and “a nationwide network of fellow matchmakers”, and lists six channels in its FAQ: an internal matchmaker database, a nationwide scout network, direct outreach, social platforms, select dating apps and client referrals. Its distinguishing claim is what happens before the date. Clients review a full profile with photos and approve or decline each match, and VIDA says nothing proceeds without that approval.

Three Day Rule describes a recruiting-led model. Its What We Offer page lists in-depth screening, date coaching, “Advanced Recruiting” (“Our team of recruiters search the country to find the perfect match”), date planning and photo guidance, and says it draws from “one of the largest and most selective networks in the country”. Its homepage invites people to “Join Our Network For Free” and complete a profile to see whether they match a client. The pages checked do not say whether clients see photos or approve matches before a date. Ask.

The guide to where matchmakers find their matches explains the difference between paying clients and free candidates, and why the size of a network matters less than how many current people fit your criteria.

Screening

VIDA’s terms say that by becoming a client you authorize a public-records background check as part of onboarding, and further screenings during the engagement at its discretion, including criminal records checks. That describes screening of clients.

Three Day Rule’s website terms of use say that, “as a matter of practice, TDR does not conduct background checks”. Its Million Dollar Matchmaking page lists “background and social checks” for matches. Read together, screening appears to differ by package, and the terms may apply to its general website services. Ask which checks apply to the people you meet and to you.

“Vetted” has no standard meaning. The guide to how matchmakers screen matches lists what each kind of check can and cannot tell you.

Guarantees and outcome claims

VIDA advertises an “82% success rate within 90 days” and says clients typically meet someone special after four to seven introductions, and that it has created more than 11,000 lasting relationships since 2009. These are the company’s own figures. The Federal Trade Commission expects advertisers to have a reasonable basis for objective claims like these (FTC substantiation policy). Ask VIDA how “success” is defined, over which clients, and in what period, before treating the number as a forecast.

VIDA’s guaranteed packages let clients decline up to two of every three matches presented, with the deliverables and refund terms set in a separate agreement. Three Day Rule’s terms of use say it does not guarantee that its matching will produce any matches, and makes no guarantee about lasting compatibility. Its homepage features client testimonials.

No matchmaker can promise that two people will fall in love. A guarantee is only as useful as the specific service obligation it describes.

If you want…Leans towardAsk before signing
A published monthly price and the option to stopVIDA SelectHow auto-renewal and cancellation work in your service agreement
To see photos and approve every match before a dateVIDA SelectHow many matches per month to expect
A recruiting-led search in a city with a local teamThree Day RuleThe written price, term and what the package includes
The most hands-on, all-inclusive tier either publishesThree Day Rule’s Million Dollar tierAvailability, screening, and the full terms behind “additional benefits”
A search outside the United StatesNeither is built for itCompare international models instead

The last row is where Match Guarantee fits. It runs international searches, which neither of these services is built around. The international matchmaking services comparison compares that kind of service, with its methodology published.

Questions to ask either service

  1. Who will actually run my search, and how many clients do they handle?
  2. What will I see about each match before a date, and can I decline?
  3. How many introductions per month does the agreement commit to?
  4. What checks are done on the people I meet, and on me?
  5. What is the full price, the term, and the cancellation and renewal policy, in writing?
  6. If you publish a success rate, how is it defined and measured?

The how to choose a matchmaker guide turns these into a worksheet you can use with any provider. Prices and terms change, so confirm everything above on each company’s own pages before you decide.

Source notes

Sources used in this guide

We link to primary research, government guidance, and the relevant Match Guarantee service pages so readers can check each material claim.

  1. 1.VIDA Select frequently asked questions · VIDA Select · Accessed November 17, 2026
  2. 2.VIDA Select terms and conditions · VIDA Select · Accessed November 17, 2026
  3. 3.The VIDA Difference · VIDA Select · Accessed November 17, 2026
  4. 4.Three Day Rule · Three Day Rule · Accessed November 17, 2026
  5. 5.What We Offer · Three Day Rule · Accessed November 17, 2026
  6. 6.Nationwide · Three Day Rule · Accessed November 17, 2026
  7. 7.Million Dollar Matchmaking · Three Day Rule · Accessed November 17, 2026
  8. 8.Terms of Use · Three Day Rule · Accessed November 17, 2026
  9. 9.FTC Policy Statement Regarding Advertising Substantiation · U.S. Federal Trade Commission · Accessed November 17, 2026

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between VIDA Select and Three Day Rule?

Both are U.S. matchmaking services with human matchmakers. VIDA Select publishes month-to-month pricing from $1,695, searches its own database, dating platforms and a network of fellow matchmakers, and lets clients approve each match from a full profile with photos. Three Day Rule operates in 15 named cities plus nationwide, describes a team of recruiters and a free candidate network, and does not publish package prices on the pages checked.

How much does VIDA Select cost?

VIDA Select says its packages range from $1,695 per month for flexible monthly memberships up to $6,000 or more for results-guaranteed programs, depending on location, goals and search depth. Its terms say monthly subscription packages may auto-renew, and the Premium Guarantee package is non-cancellable once signed.

How much does Three Day Rule cost?

Three Day Rule does not list package prices on the pages checked for this comparison. It describes memberships ranging from introductory packages to VIP memberships, plus a 12-month Million Dollar Matchmaking membership limited to three clients. Ask for the full written price, term and cancellation terms before you pay.

Does Three Day Rule do background checks?

Its website terms of use say that, as a matter of practice, Three Day Rule does not conduct background checks, while its Million Dollar Matchmaking membership lists background and social checks. Screening may therefore differ by package. Ask which checks apply to your matches and to you.

Is VIDA Select or Three Day Rule better?

Neither is better for everyone. VIDA Select may suit someone who wants published monthly pricing and to approve matches from photos first. Three Day Rule may suit someone in one of its cities who wants a recruiting-led search. Compare written terms, who runs your search and how matches are presented, not just the brand.

Joe Rickards smiling outdoors

About the author

Joe Rickards

Founder and International Matchmaking Educator

Joe founded Match Guarantee and appears throughout its public education library. His editorial focus includes matchmaking due diligence, online dating risks, service expectations, and the practical limits of any matchmaking guarantee.

  • International matchmaking
  • Matchmaking due diligence
  • Online dating risk education
View author profile